HN2new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Adam Smith gives the example of paying for roads by road tolls in his book The Wealth of Nations. In the United States, much of state and federal funding for highways is derived from a tax on gasoline and diesel vehicle fuel, to much the same effect. The ultimate incidence of ALL taxation is on consumers (and everyone is a consumer), as any competent economist will tell you. These forms of paying for roads are not socialism, by any definition of socialism that I have ever seen, but they are forms of taxation that allocate the cost of using the tax-supported, publicly available resource rather well.


> they are forms of taxation that allocate the cost of using the tax-supported, publicly available resource rather well.

...which is how socialism functions, by every definition of socialism.

But you're sidestepping the argument. In a completely nonsocialist environment, the roads wouldn't be government-funded to begin with. There would be private groups each coming up with their own free-market system for roads.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: