Hacker News .hnnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

it's funny how all the people are focussed neo malthusianism.

malthunianism isn't about the biophysics of some sustainability paradigm hatched out of a theoretical model that places massive amount of assumptions about bio blablaba.

the real malthusianism is wrapped up in the nature of the relationship between population growth relative to the political-economic societies interacting with the realities of hierarchal governance.

all socieites are based on hierarchchal pyramids of one version of cheap labor or another dominating the bottom, with dominant 1% at the top. call it capitalism, communism , or any other ism to describe every society that has almost ever existed, but the few at the top are always contending with the demographics of the many at the bottom.

in our present circumstance we have a fairly intricate global dollar/euro/yen based credit system.

the economics of the western aging population don't add up to increasing amounts of cheap labor going forward.

even in china this is a problem.

so the solution of outsourcing everything and importing streams of young immigrants (dilution of middle class) is clearly not going to work as a strategy for keeping up the stability of the banking systems and governments layered on top of the western system.

malthusianism is not so much that everything will 'collapse', but that the structure of governments and societies elite power institutions cannot remain remotely stable going into, and especially out of, population explosions.

social structure is highly dynamic in response to the bubblenomics of long term human population explosions.

world wars, failed states and many more things are deeply guaranteed by the underlying demographic realities.

bizarrely enough , it's not because there are too many people. it's because there aren't enough slaves to replenish the pen of tax producers and the pen of 'demand' for usurous credit offered by banks. when decades of pricing mortgaged assets at near zero interest rates, the banks are having a harder and harder time finding people to burden with 30 year mortgages , or as bill clinton liked to emphasize , the american dream of home foreclosureship.

eventually the price and tax reset comes (like in post soviet russia) and the clearing of the pricing and taxing system once again allows for growth in spite of the dynamic balance of debt and demographics.

then again there's always tons of high birth rates in the developing world. so long as that is the case, there's no real problems



Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: