HN2new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Thank you for the reply. Although my last sentence was probably unnecessarily combative, I hope that people reading this don't get hung up on that, how exact the math is, or how much nutrition a loaf of bread can truly provide. I mean I just looked at the cost of building the active fleet. Wikipedia estimates the total costs of the program as being roughly 4x that cost, so even taking into account the costs of a loaf of bread beyond wheat I bet that feeding the planet (with bread) for a year is still pretty close to the cost of the program.

You got what I was hoping people would take away, which is that we look at groups around the world being radicalized, turning to oppressive religion and wonder "why? what makes them do that?", and maybe one piece of the puzzle would be asking what sort of reaction these people would have if we gave everyone in their nation food for a year instead of taking a large portion of the world's total resources and expending it on war machines which we then use in their homeland.



I get your intent, but there's also the political problem in a democracy.

How hard is it to convince a majority of people that buying more death machines is a good use of their money?

Now how hard to convince a majority that feeding the world is a good use?

Now how hard to convince them that building schools is a good use?

I'll just remark that the answer to that last is why Afghanistan was controlled by the Taliban in the first place (after the warlords the US supported bickered amongst each other for a while).




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: