Hacker News .hnnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Agreed. Mr. Buffet is free to donate as much of his 'tail wind' wealth as he chooses. But please, hands off of my wallet.


He donated all of it. Whatever you got isn't that interesting.

You know, I've never had a problem with the income taxes that I pay. They're taken out of my check and I work with what's left. I never think "oh man, they're taking my money" any more than I think "oh man, I totally deserve to win the lottery".

I do think there's something about earning money through investments that makes paying taxes "feel" more like your money is being taken away from you. It's not automatically deducted. It's not there every week. Sometimes you lose money. You have to pay it all at once. Taxes are not part of the mental calculation of how much you made on that sweet stock investment. I think that's WHY the rates are lower. People just feel like the rates SHOULD be lower. But it's a psychological effect. When I look at the economic effects of the current tax scheme on a large scale, it seems to me that this kind of benefit is just a giant tax dodge.

Let's say that the tax rate is structured in a way that the cost of doing productive "work" with your capital is 30%, but the tax rate for just shuffling the money around through a bunch of investment vehicles is %15. Well, you've suddenly got a free %15 to play around with. And if you only need to return %10 to be considered a pretty good investment, then it seems like you really can't fail as long as you've already got enough money to play a different game than the rest of us. But those guys are already orbital, and the rest of us can never achieve escape velocity. I'd prefer to not live in a cyberpunk future where the rich get their own orbital gardens and the rest of us have to live in the ruins they left behind.


The main reasons capital gains are taxed at a lower rate are:

1) inflation (if you buy a stock for $100 and sell it 10y later for $120, you actually lost money, at least for every 10y period I know about)

2) invested dollars have a higher multiplier for economic activity than wages earned and then spent, so raising capital gains rates hurt the economy more ("have higher deadweight losses") than wage taxes. Poll taxes and consumption (VAT, particularly) taxes are even better, though.

3) people who have enough money to make meaningful investments tend to vote more reliably than people who earn mainly wage income, and also are in a better position to donate to political campaigns.


With the second part of item 3 being the determinant factor.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: