Hacker News .hnnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Yeah break up all the big companies so Chinese state sponsored behemoths can take over everything. This isn’t the 90s where Americans only competed with other Americans.


China is competing so well because it has a central bureaucracy that issues 5 year plans and issues money to get them done. Do you think America should do that too, or do you think America and China are different countries with different values?


Let’s not forget how much US tech came from government programs like ARPA/DARPA. It isn’t exactly a decentralized bureaucracy. Just hasn’t been hitting as well recently.


Breaking up big tech would make US markets more competitive, not less.


GP didn’t say all the big tech companies. Just Microslop.


So you're saying the market is weaker with more competition?


Nope, just break up the one that has been consistently found to be abusing their market position. Microsoft has been embroiled in this since the 90s.


Honestly not sure I find that prospect worse than the American status quo. At least the Chinese regime is a rational actor.


"America is just as bad as China" is not cute or clever; it's trite and objectively wrong. There really is no intellectually honest argument to the contrary. For starters we don't get arrested for saying "Kent State Massacre" - can't say as much for "Tiananmen Square" in China. No matter how atrocious our government may be at times, it doesn't hold a candle to them.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: