HN2new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Do all countries have something like an Italian mafia? Is there a German or British mafia of a similar scale and sophistication, but we just call them something else?




In America some non-Italian mafias do get labeled as "a mafia" by the FBI. Generally the distinguishing factors between a "gang" and a "mafia" in FBI nomenclature is scale, sophistication, and organization structure/principles. In general, it being a "family operation" (trusting blood family over government or family as government) is a large factor, and often the "omerta" principle is a requirement (that's a strong, core collective binding to secrecy; "omerta" if held as a strong principal "breaks" the prisoner's dilemma game as a law enforcement tool). The Cornbread Mafia, taken apart by the FBI in the 1980s, is one interesting example: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cornbread_Mafia

There used to be, but afaik modern networks are largely led by Balkan groups across the whole of Europe.

Most just call them the government.

Does the government engage in human trafficking, prostitution, drug trafficking, illegal gambling, racketeering, identity fraud, etc?


That was a serious question, thank you.

I think of mafia as providing services that a government/legitimate private entities cannot provide.

Human trafficking - yup, I should have thought of that. In the counties listed in the link the governments does serve that mafia function. I was US centric in my thinking.

Prostitution - no. It can be legal, but the government does not engage in it.

Drug trafficking - I am sure some governments do it. I wouldn't put US in that list. Both the government investigations and the newspaper investigations found the allegations unsupported, according to the given link. I would say it could happen incidentally but organized crime does not need to worry about the government as a competitor in this space.

Gambling - the lottery is not illegal gambling. But you can argue that is tautologically true.

Racketeering - I don't see where in that link it says that the government engages in racketeering. Rico is a law that makes prosecuting racketeering easier.


Uhm yes?

in Iran it's called IRGC

In The Netherlands it’s called D66.



Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: