HN2new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Carriers typically charge rates for both sending and receiving text messages.


I think that might just be in the USA, or at least we don't have this in the UK. It seems to me quite cheeky to charge the recipient also; you wouldn't charge someone to receive a letter.


Especially since you have no means to refuse the delivery of a text message other than telling your operator to stop delivering messages for you entirely. I have never really understood the rationale behind the US model of charging for received texts.


> I have never really understood the rationale behind the US model of charging for received texts.

Vendor charges customer because they can and customer is powerless. What about that don't you understand?

More seriously - I think it traces back to the fact that in the US you pay airtime for both incoming and outgoing calls, including "free" (1-800) numbers; The reason for this was that originally:

a) mobile calls were really expensive b) there were no number range or pattern allocated for mobile phone numbers (thus, when you call a number, you generally don't know if it is landline, mobile, virtual or which operator it is (or ever was)).

So caller-to-mobile pays the same (they don't know they are calling mobile), and recipient-on-mobile pays the rest. And since everyone was used to that, the operators extended that to text as well.


Yes, this is in the USA. And yes, it is quite cheeky. It is exactly like charging someone to receive a letter, whether they want it or not, and do so based entirely on the fact that it made it to their mailbox. It's ridiculous.


The U.S. mobile market really needs a shake-up if you've got to pay for what you receive even if you haven't asked for it.


Yes, it really rubs salt in the wound when you get a spam text and then realize that cost me money.


Indeed it does. My understanding of the standing of mobile carriers in the legal system leaves me to think this shake-up is not so easily accomplished. From texting to tethering, we're charged to use every feature our phones include if the carriers can delimit some kind of usage of it (even though the actual usage is not different from, say, merely using our data plans).


UK/France/Spain and most european countries have got good deals. Under 40$ a month for all unlimited, and many MVNO offer 4 cent/minute or text and a fixed ~20cent per call rate, pay as you go (data is very cheap, too). Inbound texts or calls are of course free (except when abroad).

Roaming is currently around 9ct/mb in the european union if you manage to get the right deal, or by law 80ct/mb which isn't _that_ good.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: