HN2new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

These folks knowingly chose to spend the rest of their careers explaining that they are not, in fact, S3.


(Founder) well 50% of our name is different


I like it. I see it as ostensibly a product for engineers and so when I see a name like S2 it's immediately clear that it's a product led and conceived by engineers.

I also see that on your pricing page -

"We are building the S3 experience for streaming data, and that includes pricing transparency"

Love the simple and earnest copy. One can imagine what an LLM would cook up instead, I find the brevity way preferable.


(Founder) Thank you for the kind comment!

Yes we are not trying to confuse S2 with S3, we just think S3 is the best damn serverless experience out there, and we aspire to that greatness. We borrowed the structure of that name to reflect that aspiration, as have other services inspired by S3 like Cloudflare's object store R2.


I actually thought S2 is a Cloudflare service at first.


You should have gone with S4 tbh. The suits love bigger numbers. Super Simple Stream Store.


http://www.supersimplestorageservice.com/ exists and calls itself S4. It's a decent gag and the immediately came to mind when I heard S2 vs S3.


(Founder) I have definitely received that advice before :) - to not seem like a regression from S3. But as an abbreviation for Stream Store, it made sense.


Why not just use SS? There can’t possibly be any negative connotations there.


You could even make the s look kind of like a lightning bolt to emphasize how fast it is


Quite dangerous. Will look almost like the Schutzstaffel runic insignia. I'd better avoid this resemblance.


thatsthejoke.jpg


SS .. as in nazi?


Reserved by GM for the Super Sport


So that's why GM has been asking itself "Are we the baddies?" lately.


S3++?


How do you store a stream? Don’t they just spray around the internet here and there, and if you don’t catch them in the moment, they’re just gone?


(Founder) I thought you were joking but coming back it could well be serious :)

When we say stream, we really mean The Log that Jay Kreps has a famous blog about https://engineering.linkedin.com/distributed-systems/log-wha...

We say stream because we would rather not be confused with "logs" as in application logs, but rather associate with the world of streaming data where this primitive is very relevant. We don't mean stream as in a TCP stream or live stream.

You can, however stream Star Wars on S2 ;-) https://s2.dev/docs/quickstart#get-started-with-the-cli


Surely S3++? /s


Disagree. You have a marketing opportunity for a hipster character named "Stu" to be the spokesman.


Disco Stu don't advertise


Props to you for having a sense of humor about it. :D

If I could put in one request...a video which describes what it is and how to use it would make it easier for me to understand.


(Founder) Yes we should create a video, thanks for the feedback.

In the meantime, checkout this quickstart which will have to streaming Star Wars with the S2 CLI and give you a pretty good sense of things https://s2.dev/docs/quickstart#get-started-with-the-cli

(You will have to apply to join the preview, but we are approving quickly)


You could say that. Or, in binary ASCII, you could say your name is 93.75% the same (it flips only the last bit of 16).


Your 66.66% (2/3) of the way there to the second character too. So I would say your only 16.66% different across the two characters.


I would look much more into Levenshtein Distance ;) if I would like to be smart ass funny.


You're 50% of the way closer to 1st!


How many of these letter-number storage services are there now? S3, B2, R2, S2...


S3 isn't the name of the service - that's "Amazon Simple Storage Service". S3 is a nickname, short for "Simple Storage Service".


Nickname implies it's unofficial, but S3 is very much the product name too:

https://aws.amazon.com/s3/faqs/

"Simple storage service" is used once. "S3" is used throughout.


While you’re technically correct, for all intents and purposes it is called S3 even by AWS themselves.


When I was a student we had a Facebook group to share information, and one angry guy ranted that the correct shortening of "Mathematical Analysis" is not, in fact, "anal", as we were used to say


and EC2 stands for "Elastic Compute Cloud". but no one remembers that.



Seems preferable to having to explain you're not a paramilitary organization responsible for unspeakable war crimes. Nothing funny about that.


Including potentially in court / to lawyers? IANAL, but isn't this just inviting Amazon to claim it's deliberately leveraging their 'S3' trademark and sowing confusion in order to lift their own brand? (Correctly, and even somewhat transparently in TFA, IMO.)


My issue is that 2<3 and for most people they will just assume its older/shittier S3 lol




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: