HN2new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Not that US institutions don't lie, but our bureaucracy and government oversight systems come with the benefit that many of the things we track and document can be verified. Other countries simply lie. The numbers you get are not a rough approximation of reality; they're simply part of whatever story that country wants to tell.

Crime rate is a statistic for which a majority of countries provide numbers that are completely dissociated from reality.

You can, of course, take the numbers seriously, as if the statistics are being published in good faith. Unless you have some sort of independent oversight, however, that isn't beholden to or biased by the country being assessed, then taking those numbers seriously is probably a silly thing to do.

The US gets lots of independent verification and validation of crime statistics. They're frequently analyzed at local, state, and federal level by journalists, students, activists, authors, and government officials. At every level an official number is published, it gets challenged, so there are incentives keeping the politicians and bureaucrats honest. They get slammed when they get caught lying, and they get caught lying because the public and the media keep track of things and demand accountability.

Some stuff, like total officer involved shootings, dog shootings by officials, abuses of power, and things of that nature, don't get publicly disclosed much of the time, so there are gaps in what we know and what officials are required to disclose.

The US isn't perfect, but you can get pretty good numbers that actually correlate with reality. Even other western countries don't always have trustworthy reporting and accounting for government actions. The best you'll ever get is a glowing narrative.



You're not wrong, however when it comes to NYC statistically it is the safest in the US. However this is mostly looking at murder/capita.

It does not account for the 1000s of illegal small assaults that happen daily. Anyone spending time in NYC will eventually run into this.

But then you get the one person who says "I've never been mugged" or "I've never been punched" or a journalist vists for a day and says it's all fine.

Meanwhile there is a lot of stockholm syndrome of what QoL people put up with on a day to day basis.


Singapore has very low levels of corruption. Even lower than in the United States. You can choose to dismiss them, but I think their numbers are reliable.


This post should be stickied at the top of this topic.


Such a long text for "their numbers are better than ours, they are clearly liars"




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: