Hacker News .hnnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

[flagged]


> Some people believe that whether you're a woman or a man is a thought in your head, and they also believe that these thoughts mean you can be neither, which they call 'non-binary'. It's helpful to respect these people's beliefs and act as if they are true, because they can get very angry and vindictive if you don't agree with them.

And then we ask why some kids wind up entrenched away from economic opportunity…

Like, if your only coping mechanisms for beliefs you disagree with—particularly about someone else’s private affairs—rise out of fear of retribution, you shouldn’t be in a decision-making role of any kind. It’s somewhat sad to see that baked into a kid from the get go, but maybe they’ll get over it without winding up resentful for the handicap.


The point is it's not a private affair. Retribution from people who react harmfully when others do not share their beliefs is a real thing, ask anyone who was brought up in a strict religious environment who became a non-believer. Sometimes the easiest path is minimal appeasement to avoid conflict where you'll end up worse off.


> it's not a private affair

Someone's sexuality or gender identity sure is. Given languages' pronouns evolve (e.g. a universal "you" in place of the informal "thou", or the aborted deprecation of "y'all"), that's not a reasonable hang-up.

> the easiest path is minimal appeasement to avoid conflict where you'll end up worse off

Sure, and instinctive conflict avoidance is a valid life strategy. It's just bad build for a decision maker. Someone conditioned in that behaviour is going into life with opportunities cordoned off.


Rarely is the virtuous path the easiest.


Meanwhile, other people get angry when such people’s mere existence is revealed to children!


That's quite an opinion you've put in quote marks there. Such a pity you've not thought about how a hypothetical Bluey episode might cover that topic.


Perhaps you should teach children that it's good to respect people's beliefs because being nice to people is good?

I think it's ironically tragic that in an attempt to get people to respect your beliefs more, you argue that the main reason to do so it out of fear of retribution.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: