HN2new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Even many agricultural societies still had seasonal nomadic tendencies during which they hunted and gathered. Many sedentary societies lived and worked communally without much social stratification. The reason we associate agriculture with centralization is that centralized agricultural societies conquered the others, not that centralization is inherent to agriculture.


To elaborate on this point: without agriculture centralization wasn't advantageous (or possible) but with agriculture centralization is advantageous--so centralized societies outcompete and are "selected for" over non-centralized societies and we end up with a "genotype" of societies having the trait of centralization.


Who did the Sumerians conquer? Seems like they just found a fertile area & stayed there.


Doesn't matter for the point I made. Where does the country of Sumer rule today?


It's remanded to the sands of time. That tends to happen to civilizations that started 7000 years ago.


They were destroyed by Gozer the Gozerian.


Lol




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: