Hacker News .hnnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Seems like speculation / projection. If your argument about unions and extremism was supported, you’d expect to see a correlation between high union membership and “extremism”. If anything, countries with high union density (Sweden, Iceland, Finland) seem to have fewer extremist parties than low union countries like the United States, The Philippines, and Poland. In the United States, the long-term decline in industrial union power, as also seen in Great Britain during the Thatcher “union-busting” era, has presided over an increase in extremism.

So whatever effect union has in employment, it’s not the kind that is shown to lead to extremism.

Again, you cited a paper claiming that it supported that “unions == unemployment” when all it said was that unions are correlated with small increases in unemployment among the very young and very old.

What we know is that union membership is shown definitively to result in better working conditions and safety, higher job satisfaction, and higher wages across entire industries.



> Again, you cited a paper claiming…

I cited no such thing but merely pulled an opinion out of my backside.

I’m really just saying that maybe it isn’t such a good idea to intentionally restrict young people from the job market because they have the exact same right to meaningful employment as anyone else.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: