HN2new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

It might have to do with the fact that he's using rubber bands to turn the arm, while historical trebuchets used weights. A weight is limited in how fast it can accelerate so you need to use a lever (the arm) to increase the speed.


Springs could be used instead of rubber bands. While "coil spring" is a relatively modern invention, other kinds of springs are known from the Bronze Age, accoding to https://www.designingbuildings.co.uk/wiki/History_of_the_Spr...


Springs are much older than that, the bow is perhaps the most famous example from antiquity.


And they can be quite formidable, a full size wooden (yew, maple, ash) bow takes a lot of arm strength to properly pull. Just a few shots and you'll be wishing for stronger muscles.


You can double the muscle power available by using a foot-bow.


Good point. I somehow was thinking about metal springs (Romans used springs from lead, for instance), but there's no reason to restrict it to metal.


Lead springs? They'd have to be absurdly oversized by modern standards to hold up to any kind of force without deforming, I'd imagine. I'd love to read more about them, if you happen to have a cite handy.


I don’t reckon.

Surely the above comment is confused, misremembering leaf spring as lead spring.

Leaf springs appeared as early as the Roman empire as a form of primitive suspension for chariots and other two-wheelers. Instead of steel, savvy Romans used flexible wooden sticks.

https://connect2local.com/l/112910/c/478618/examining-the-fa...


Thank you. This is exactly the mistake I made.

It raised some flags in my head when I read it, but then again - Romans did so many things out of lead that I did not challenge it.


Ah, yeah, that makes a lot more sense.


Torsion springs are another option.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Torsion_siege_engine


You could use a weight combined with pulleys or gears to get a faster acceleration.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: