Hacker News .hnnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

"...developers care more about this stuff..."

No, they only care when the tools they are using are targeted. Otherwise, they couldn't care less.

We have tracking on websites and in apps on an industrial scale - built by developers in technology companies. We even have tracking of school kids courtesy of ChromeOS. When have developers ever shown any care about that? When have they ever spoken out about that? They're more likely to rush to defend that software and the company that built it: It's not being used to build profiles, or the data is aggregated and anonymous.

Presumably, if GitLab tracked behaviour 'anonymously' and in aggregate form, that would all be fine? Didn't think so. The hypocrisy that runs through the programming profession when it comes to online tracking really knows no end.



If I had a guarantee from Gitlab that _they_ were scrubbing the data, I would have no problem. I get the sense they know what they're doing (naive, maybe)

However, giving a third party script, potentially unvetted, access to the crown jewels of the company I work for? No fucking way.

Different. Not a double standard.


They are tracking things anonymously at least in some places, judging by what I've read in the linked Gitlab issue tracker threads. The debacle started with someone higher up requesting to start recording user ID with that data, in order for the "growth team" to be able to do "experiments".




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: