I've been considering negotiating part-time with my employer for awhile as a prudent middle ground between recklessly jumping ship (a la https://hackernews.hn/item?id=1451175) and continuing to let my UI project crawl along at a near-standstill.
Your listed caveats help me form a good picture of what I should be ready to concede. Any more tips on negotiating? I know there are always a lot of variables from company to company, but was it hard to keep full benefits?
I wish I could say that I drove a hard bargain to get full benefits, but it happens to be company policy. I went in to the meeting prepared to increase my portion of the cost of my healthcare if necessary.
My biggest concerns prior to initiating the negotiations were 1) affecting morale if someone else is forced to compensate for my reduced hours, 2) the fact that I occasionally do freelance mobile development on the side, and 3) possibly being let go as my company is going through a downsizing. So far, it hasn't been an issue, but it's early.
It turns out that my freelance work is a non-issue according to my employment contract and IP agreement. I didn't really reduce my hours to do freelance work. Instead, I was doing freelance work to insure some modest income should I be forced to resign, and I may reduce my efforts there since I can easily live just on the income from my part-time work. My boss and his boss were cool about the freelancing, but they told me to keep it to myself, and I wish that I had been more private about my side interests prior to asking to go part time.
In your case, I would check up on the IP situation. You don't really want to be in a position where there are questions about who owns your side project.
As far as negotiating tips, what worked for me - I don't know that this is great advice necessarily but I had to do it this way because it addressed the worst case scenario in terms of short-term income - was that I was resolved to resign, even though it wasn't really my first choice in improving my situation. However, I have about 1 year's living expenses saved up and I'm making close to $1K a week doing 20 hours of freelance mobile development and turning down projects just about every day. That gave me the confidence to start the conversation by saying, "I am considering resigning." Eventually, I suggested the work schedule that I was willing to consider. I had researched the company HR site to know what options were available to me. I also felt reasonably confident that they want me to stay and that it would be hard to replace me, at least in the short term.
One thing that is bad about bringing up resignation is that it will likely keep you from collecting unemployment if your employer plays hard ball. I never said "I resign," just that I was considering it, but I have been advised since then that it was probably a bad idea from that standpoint. It probably didn't matter in my case because I wouldn't be eligible anyway due to my freelance income.
Also, I have a very friendly relationship with my boss, so that helps a lot. It seemed that he really wanted to help me, and he played up the cost savings angle up the management ladder to help me get what I wanted.
Having been in a similar situation ("I need to resign or work part time"), I think the best thing you can do is show awareness of the effect it will have on your coworkers and suggest ways in which this will work out.
For example: "I suggest I keep the 60% of my job that is the most onerous for someone else to take and/or requires the most prior experience and/or is best matched to my skills. As for the other 40%, I suggest task A should go to Fred - he is ready for more experience, it will be good for him. Task B can be phased out when the new project is completed anyway. Jane has agreed to roll in Task C with the similar Task D that she already performs".
I have been doing this for several years, and it has worked out great for everybody. The only issue is whether the tasks you give up are important for your career development - sometimes they are, so you will have to make some serious choices.
Your listed caveats help me form a good picture of what I should be ready to concede. Any more tips on negotiating? I know there are always a lot of variables from company to company, but was it hard to keep full benefits?