Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login
How machine logic infects our tastes (reallifemag.com)
55 points by anjalik on May 27, 2017 | hide | past | favorite | 7 comments



No one is surprised that people in tropical climates like spicy foods, or that people near the Mediterranean like olive oil while people further north like butter. People's tastes adapt to what they have. That's a great thing about us. Now, we're a society with very cheap computing power. It's no surprise that we grow to like the foods such a society makes.


how is spicy food the only thing the tropic has? I always thought it preserved the food better.


I didn't mean "what they have" in an exclusive sense. Tropical regions have access to spices and a reason to use them, as you said, so the people get to like them more than people elsewhere. Of course they also have foods that are not spicy.


I was going for an explanation that spicy food was preserved better in the warm humid climate.


Homo sapiens the toolmaker. Once you make a tool, you inevitably end up adapting your "process" (and admittedly that term is tool-oriented in the extreme, especially to an epicureanist) to fit the tool.

Dmitry Orlov talks about the idea of a "technosphere" (analogous to the "biosphere"), that is made by us but also seems to have its own will, and "it tries" to remake us in its own image. Interesting reading:

https://www.amazon.com/Shrinking-Technosphere-Technologies-A...


The major activities of the individual must directly satisfy his own creative and emotional impulses, must always be something more than means to an end. The great cultural fallacy of industrialism, as developed up to the present time, is that in harnessing machines to our uses it has not known how to avoid the harnessing of the majority of mankind to its machines.

The telephone girl who lends her capacities, during the greater part of the living day, to the manipulation of a technical routine that has an eventually high efficiency value but that answers to no spiritual needs of her own is an appalling sacrifice to civilisation. As a solution of the problem of culture she is a failure — the more dismal the greater her natural endowment. As with the telephone girl, so, it is to be feared, with the great majority of us, slave-stokers to fires that burn for demons we would destroy, were it not that they appear in the guise of our benefactors.

The American Indian who solves the economic problem with salmon-spear and rabbit-snare operates on a relatively low level of civilisation, but he represents an incomparably higher solution than our telephone girl of the questions that culture has to ask of economics. There is here no question of the immediate utility, of the effective directness, of economic effort, nor of any sentimentalizing regrets as to the passing of the "natural man."

The Indian's salmon-spearing is a culturally higher type of activity than that of the telephone girl or mill hand simply because there is normally no sense of spiritual frustration during its prosecution, no feeling of subservience to tyrannous yet largely inchoate demands, because it works in naturally with all the rest of the Indian's activities instead of standing out as a desert patch of merely economic effort in the whole of life.

A genuine culture cannot be defined as a sum of abstractly desirable ends, as a mechanism. It must be looked upon as a sturdy plant growth, each remotest leaf and twig of which is organically fed by the sap at the core. And this growth is not here meant as a metaphor for the group only; it is meant to apply as well to the individual.

A culture that does not build itself out of the central interests and desires of its bearers, that works from general ends to the individual, is an external culture. The word "external," which is so often instinctively chosen to describe such a culture, is well chosen. The genuine culture is internal, it works from the individual to ends.

-Edward Sapir


Oh, that's the tool-artist relationship. That lots of successful work comes from highly constrained settings.

Doing a design? You have 1/10th the time or 1/20th the time as you'd like. Any other radical constraint.

Yea, feedback.




Consider applying for YC's W25 batch! Applications are open till Nov 12.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: