HN2new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

>Representative democracy is intended to limit the ability of the majority to shoehorn the minority

That is a benefit of certain aspects of our political system, but not the electoral college. The electoral college only serves to introduce bizarre volatility into the elections.



This is a nice sound bite (kind of), but doesn't bear out the actual facts. The EC was designed specifically to ensure that States (in the big-S, Constitutional meaning) decide the President, not the people.


That's true, but doesn't really contradict what I said.


It directly contradicts the last line of your statement. The EC does not exist "to introduce bizarre volatility"


Allowing states to control the elections is a mean not an end. Given that the vote of states are determined by a popular vote within the state, the only end that is accomplished by the EC is introducing volatility.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: