HN2new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | erelong's commentslogin

we really need to build up a third party linux mobile ecosystem as an alternative to the ios / android duopoly

Right? It helps accelerate creative output when used well...

I've been seeing a lot of posts like this and I don't tend to agree with the "anti-AI sentiment", but I think some of the problems identified might be like this:

People may lack ideas of interesting projects to work on in the first place; so we need to think about how to help people to think of useful and interesting projects to work on

Related to that idea, people may need to develop skills for building more "complex" ideas and we may need to think about how to make that more possible in the era of AI usage... even if some AI agent can take care of a technical side of things, it still takes a kind of "complexity of thought" to dream up more complicated / useful / interesting projects (I get the impression that there may be a need for some kind of training of the mind necessary for asking for an "automobile" rather than a "faster horse", by analogy... and that conception was often found through manually tinkering with intermediate devices like the bicycle. Hence an AI could "one shot" something interesting but what that thing is is limited by the imagination of the user, which may be limited by technical inability - in other words, the user may need to develop more technical ability in order to be able to dream up more interesting things to create, even if this "technical ability" is a more "skilled usage of AI tools")

There needs to be some way to filter through "noise". That's not a new issue and... a lot of these questions or complaints often feel very "meta", as in - you could just ask AI how to make side projects more interesting or useful, or how to create good filters in the age of AI. In sports, there are hierarchical levels of competition - likewise here you might have forums that are more closed off to newcomers if you want to "gatekeep" things, and they have to compete in "local pools" of attention and if they "win" there, then their "qualified authority / leader" submits the project to a higher level, and so on. AI suggests using qualified curators to create newsfeeds or to act as filters of the "slop".


I feel similarly but if people want to hate on AI, they're free to do so I guess

Opposite of my experience, I think AI gives tools to expand thinking and creativity significantly, leading to much more interesting results

Upper middle absolutely causes a lot of problems; surprised more people aren't focused on them

It’s easier for the top 10% to blame the top 0.1% and absolve themselves, in spite of the knowledge that this changes nothing. Americans especially are averse to the idea that the middle class owes anything to anyone.

IOW alot of the parents of the young people who are complaining quite a bit themselves.

Sorry, on HN I wasn't expecting any attention from somebody who is fully convinced that no young people have parents, or something like that.

I'm curious what an ai optimist article looks like in contrast to this pessimistic (even if possibly realistic) take

Let me add some constraints: AI optimists that aren’t selling me “how to use vercel to make $1M per week in 10 minutes”

I love AI, I enjoy using it at work. I fear AI, the amount of work it does for me feels existentially threatening. We live in exhilarating times.


Fair to say it's not an addiction but habit forming?

Just like food, gaming, exercise, certain drugs...?

For example with certain drug addictions there is a direct physical danger of overdose which doesn't exist in the same way with social media


I think it's just that grammar is independent of getting results; so bosses who might get results might also have bad grammar. Having good grammar doesn't make you any more able to get things done - in other words, someone with bad grammar might be more able to get things fone than someone with good grammar

Honestly even before AI, open source or other things made it possible to skip a lot of subscriptions

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: