Hacker News .hnnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | donohoe's commentslogin

I hate chatbot for situations like this but I get the reasons here. That said, I was hoping to get info on how it actually performed - nothing. There is nothing to suggest there is a clear metric for success and no hint of one either.

It’s just the euphoria of building something, but zilch about impact.


Typically most primary sources are public.

Nope.

CNN, CNBC, NYPost, Guardian all had stories up quickly, or around an hour. There are others too.

UPDATED:

Down-votes happen but disappointing since I'm stating facts. Heres some backup:

The user haunter said media started reporting around ~4 AM EST (based on timestamps).

The accident happened at 11:40 PM EST. Story publish times across a sample of various legacy/mainstream media orgs:

  CNN - 12:47 AM
  NYPost - 12:47 AM
  The Guardian - 12:50 AM
  Associated Press (AP) - 1:31 AM
  Fox News - 1:47 AM
  Newsweek - 2:24 AM
There are others.

The first Harry Potter ebook (with art) was about 1.3mb.

The average news article text (only) is usually less than 20 kb.


Opera Mini used to load many pages in <20kb.

“North America puts man on the moon”

Yes. Yes it is.


Now let's evaluate "America puts man on moon"

Its a common term for the USA that has no other meaning. The content is North America, the two continents are the Americas. No ambiguity.

Europe properly means the continent so it is far more like saying "North America puts man on moon" than saying "America puts man on moon".

Ambiguity is always bad.

Some people say its clear, but I am sure a lot of others thought an EU agency reconnected with a spacecraft.

Its interesting that people get so upset about asking for correct and unambiguous language.


“America” has no other meaning? So USA means United States of USA?

Exactly, their name is a zip bomb.

Doing recursive acronyms centuries before it was cool.

> Its a common term for the USA that has no other meaning

Except, you know, the only “other” meaning of “America” is just literally the alternative name for Americas, both continents. Here is an obscure link to the description [0]. Even if you want to refer to North America, what about Mexico and Canada?

The less you know, the less ambiguous it is.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Americas


Didn't think it was possible, but yes, you made it even worse.

A good title is brief and clear.

"'Miracle': European Space Agency reconnects with lost spacecraft" is long.

"'Miracle': ESA reconnects with lost spacecraft" is opaque.

The first four words of the article are, "The European Space Agency..."


ESA is one of the largest space agencies in the world. There’s nothing opaque about calling it ESA especially in a title. We wouldn’t use initialisms if everything had to be expanded all the time.

So is Roscosmos, but in such a situation, "Russia reconnects with lost spacecraft" would be the more accessible title

Personally I would prefer to call it "Roscosmos/ESA connects..." than "Russia/Europe connects". It adds information for free while keeping it short, just put it in the title. ESA is more specific than Europe or EU, so why make the title more generic and opaque than needed? It tells you it's not a random team of "Europeans", it's not an amateur hacker in the backyard, or some intelligence agency.

The expansion isn't really needed when it's a "household name" in the field. If you read a title about space industry there's no need to expand or explain NASA, ESA, Roscosmos, maybe not even for ISRO or JAXA, although I can see how some of these wouldn't be the most familiar for people in the West even when they have some interest in space news.


Chuck Norris doesn't upvote on Hacker News. His presence alone sends posts to the front page. No more.

Here is the most frustrating part:

Publishers could create efficient fast-loading web pages if they prioritized it (and a rare few do) but its just not a priority for most even though its in their best interest.

You can have ads loading on a web page, even with header bidders, if you structure it correctly. In fact you can implement an ad solution that allows for fast loading pages and better optimize your ad revenue - whether you're doing pragmatic or direct.

I know this because I've done this before. At a past employer we cleaned up their mobile version (they used the "m.example.com" format, so we could push this as a separate rogue experiment) and saw ad revenue grow by over 30% while giving readers a better, faster overall UX.

I actively monitor top publisher article pages and you can see how bad (and good) it is:

https://webperf.xyz/

TL;DR Keep using an ad blocker


Wow, it’s really interesting to see the sudden unchanged nautil.us made around the 4th of March!

The Test URL is a 404 for me though - if that's what the data is based on, it might not be completely fair...

This is very cool, nicely done.

One note: the Property link, that links to the actual news source, is broken.

Also, the test link you're using for Nautilus (the top scoring site) is 404 (https://nautil.us/issue/48/chaos/the-multiverse-as-muse)


Fixed the URL for Nautilus. Updates will roll in over the next 24 hours as tests happen and it averages out.

Its on my roadmap to auto-update the URL over time to avoid this very thing!

Thx to those who pointed it out.


This is pretty cool!

I started on this when project when I was at The New Yorker. I had just manage to convince people to give us space to do web performance optimization - and then we had to drop it quickly to work on AMP. Very frustrating.

This site was created to give developers and pms some ammunition to work on improving load speed

https://webperf.xyz/


The leader https://nautil.us on your board is incredibly fast!


Great project and we definitely need to maintain these public lists. Well done!


Its describing every second LinkedIn post, no?


LinkedIn is the worst purgatory world of this study for sure.


I would love to hear more about this “open secret” - especially the guidance on how to “mask the output” etc. because as someone who works in news/media it’s news to me.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: